Sutton is a two-time Tony Award winner: she earned the 2011 Tony Award for her most recent role as Reno Sweeney in The Roundabout’s revival of Anything Goes, and the 2002 Tony Award for her performance as Millie Dillmount in Thoroughly Modern Millie, a role she created in the 2000 La Jolla Playhouse premiere. She also received the 2011 Drama Desk, Outer Critics Circle, Astaire, and Broadway.com’s Audience Favorite Awards for Anything Goes, as well as the 2002 Drama Desk, Outer Critics Circle, and Astaire Awards for Millie.
Previous Broadway leading roles include Princess Fiona in Shrek: The Musical (2008 Tony and Drama Desk nominations, Outer Critics Circle Award); Inga in Mel Brooks’s Young Frankenstein; Janet Van De Graff in The Drowsy Chaperone (2006 Tony and Drama Desk nominations, LA Ovation Award); and Jo March in Little Women – The Musical (2005 Tony, Drama Desk, and Outer Critics Circle nominations).
Other Broadway credits include Les Miserables, Annie, The Scarlet Pimpernel, and Grease!. Regional productions include What the World Needs Now (Old Globe), Dorian (Goodspeed), The Three Musketeers (San Jose Musical Theater), Nellie Forbush in South Pacific and Sally in Me and My Girl (both at Pittsburgh CLO). She has toured nationally in The Will Rogers Follies, Les Miserables, and Grease!.
Sweet Charity
2016-2017
The Pershing Square Signature Center
Role: Charity
 DETAILS |  VIDEOS
|
The Wild Party
2015
New York City Center
Role: Queenie
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Violet
2014
American Airlines Theatre
Role: Violet
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
 .
Anything Goes
2011-2012
Stephen Sondheim Theatre
Role: Reno Sweeney
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Trust
2010
Second Stage Theatre
Role: Prudence
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
 .
They’re Playing Our Song
Actor’s Fund Benefit Performance
August 30th, 2010
Gerald W. Lynch Theatre at John Jay College
Role: Sonia Walsk
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
 .
Anyone Can Whistle
Encores! Great American Musicals in Concert
2010
City Center Mainstage
Role: Nurse Fay Apple
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Shrek the Musical
2008-2010
Original Broadway Production
Broadway Theatre
Role: Princess Fiona
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Young Frankenstein
2007-2009
Original Broadway Production
Hilton Theatre
Role: Inga
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
The Drowsy Chaperone
2006-2007
Original Broadway Production
Marquis Theatre
Role: Janet Van De Graaff
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Little Women – The Musical
2005
Original Broadway Production
Virginia Theatre
Role: Jo
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
.
Me and My Girl
8/3/2004-8/8/2004
Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera
Role: Sally Smith
DETAILS |
Snoopy! The Musical
New York Concert
April 12, 2004
Peter Norton Symphony Space
Role: Peppermint Patty
DETAILS |
Chess
Actors’ Fund Concert
September 22, 2003
Role: Svetlana |
Funny Girl
Actors’ Fund Concert
September 23, 2002
New Amsterdam Theater
Role: Fanny Brice |
 .
Thoroughly Modern Millie
Original Broadway Production
2002-2004
Marquis Theatre
Role: Millie Dillmount
DETAILS | VIDEOS |
Dorian
World Premiere
2000
Chester, CT (Regional)
Role: Sister Claire
DETAILS |
The Scarlet Pimpernel
Original Broadway Production
1997
Minskoff Theatre/Neil Simon Theatre
Role: Ensemble<
DETAILS
|
Annie
Broadway Revival
1997
Martin Beck Theatre
Roles: A Star to Be, Cecille, Dog Catcher,
Ensemble, Ronnie Boylan
DETAILS |
Grease
Broadway Revival
1994-1998
Eugene O’Neill Theatre/National Tour
Role: Sandy Dumbrowski [Replacement]
DETAILS |
Les Misérables
Broadway Production
1987
Roles: Female Ensemble [Replacement],
Eponine (Understudy) [Replacement]
DETAILS |
The Will Rogers Follies
The National Tour
Directed by Tommy Tune |
What the World Needs Now
1998
Old Globe Theatre |
The Three Musketeers
American Musical Theatre of San Jose |
South Pacific
Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera |
